November 12, 2026
In June 2025, the new owner of the Landing building at 300 Admiral Way told the Port of Edmonds that Arnies was "open and operating as usual and remains the heart of the Landing building." My Edmonds News reported the same week that Arnies and the building's other tenants would stay open until construction began, which was estimated for sometime in 2029.
Fifteen months later, the restaurant posted a sign on its door.
"After 45 years of service, Arnies Restaurant will close effective September 21, 2026. Unfortunately, the current business climate does not allow us to continue."
My Edmonds News printed the full text the next day. The sign thanked guests for "so many memories, friendships, first dates, holidays, birthdays, proposals, and Anniversaries." The Edmonds Beacon also reported the September 21 closure.
The most recent published construction estimate for the hotel that will replace the building is still that June 2025 figure of sometime in 2029. The restaurant closed in September 2026. Whatever happens on that stretch of Admiral Way over the next few winters fills the space between those two dates.
The building's lease history also points to 2029. According to the Port of Edmonds, the longtime building owner, Catspaw LLC, told the Port in early 2024 that it would not extend its ground lease, which ran to the end of 2029. Catspaw then brought in 1010 Development, the company of local father-and-son partners Mike and Ryan Appleby, as a candidate to take over.
From there, the steps went like this:
The project itself is a boutique wellness hotel. The Port's announcement lists the public pieces as a full-service restaurant, a sauna and spa, a social club, event space, and a first-floor café serving coffee, smoothies, and grab-and-go items. Appleby told My Edmonds News the footprint would stay the same but the building would be completely torn down. He also mentioned the Sunday-morning cold-water plungers as one reason to put sauna services on the ground floor.
The Port described the design as preliminary. It also said the project still faces "an extensive permitting and approval process, including a design review with opportunities for public input." Until that process runs its course, the Landing is an existing building with one fewer tenant.
The Port's June 2025 announcement said the building would stay in retail and office use "for the foreseeable future." Appleby said his "first order of business is to fill the building vacancies." His first new tenant was Snoqualmie Gourmet Ice Cream.
That shop is open at 300 Admiral Way, Suite 102. My Edmonds News reported it open by March 8, 2026. Hours have changed since spring. Snoqualmie's scoop shop page now lists the Edmonds shop as open Wednesday through Sunday, noon to 8 p.m. Arnies' closure left the building's newest tenant as its best-known one: a scoop shop that keeps a five-day week through November.
Catspaw's managing member, Peter Challman, described the building's history to the Port this way: "From restaurants to butcher shops, marine yacht brokers to insurance salespeople, The Landing has been home to many." Tenants have come and gone there for decades, and for 45 of those years Arnies was among them.
For a dinner with the ferry and the Olympics in view, the nearest option is now down the same street at 456 Admiral Way. Two Anthony's restaurants share that building, one stacked on top of the other.
| Anthony's HomePort | Anthony's Beach Cafe | |
|---|---|---|
| Address | 456 Admiral Way | 456 Admiral Way |
| Floor | Upstairs | Downstairs |
| Format | Waterfront dining room overlooking the ferry and the Salish Sea | Casual, walk-in dining at the water's edge |
| Listed hours | Mon.–Thu. 4–8:30 p.m.; Fri.–Sat. 4–9 p.m.; Sun. 10 a.m.–8:30 p.m. | Daily, 11:30 a.m.–8:30 p.m. |
Anthony's Edmonds page describes HomePort's views as Puget Sound and the Olympic Mountains. HomePort's schedule makes it an evening-and-Sunday room, while the Beach Cafe downstairs covers lunch and early dinner every day. In late November, when sunset comes well before HomePort's weekday dinner service gets going, the downstairs café is the one that lines up with the light.
Arnies left a different gap a few blocks inland. Salt & Iron at 321 Main Street lists dinner and weekend brunch and says it closes on Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, and New Year's Day. For anyone planning holiday meals around the downtown core this year, Arnies is no longer an option, and those four dates matter at other restaurants too.
The closure also left a practical question, and a lot of Edmonds households are asking it. The columnist who covered it for My Edmonds News wrote that her own family had an unused card "of significant value."
In a September 29 follow-up, My Edmonds News reported that Arnies' controller said attorneys would contact holders "in the coming weeks about outstanding gift card balances." The paper also reprinted a letter giving notice, under RCW 24.03A, of the pending dissolution of Arnie's Restaurants Northwest, Inc. That letter asks anyone with a claim against the corporation to send a final invoice to [email protected], and says the corporation will reply with instructions for filing a formal claim.
The same article reported that Hook & Cleaver in Mukilteo, which used to be another Arnies location, offered a discount to diners who turn in an Arnies gift card: $10 off a $50 purchase or $25 off a $100 purchase. The offer runs until Thanksgiving 2026. Thanksgiving falls on November 26 this year.
This section reports a published notice and a restaurant's offer. It is general information, not legal or financial advice. If you hold a card, confirm your options with the company's claim process or a qualified professional.
Arnies' closure came the same fall that downtown got a new restaurant opening, a few hundred yards up from the water. Chef and mixologist Niles Peacock, who also runs Niles Peacock Kitchen & Bar, opened Rooster Bagel Cafe • Kitchen • Bar at 515 Main St. on Saturday, October 3. Rooster took over the building that used to house The Loft.
"The folks in Edmonds kept saying, 'We need bagels,'" Chief Operating Officer Hillary Ness told The Everett Herald. Rooster opened with hours of 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. daily and four sourdough bagel flavors: plain, everything, cheese, and Maldon Salt. Espresso is made with Forecast Coffee Company beans. The Herald reported plans for cocktails, beer, wine, and adaptogen-based mocktails "this fall and winter," along with longer hours once the staff settles in.
Around the corner at 504 5th Ave. S., Girardi's Osteria introduced a redesigned menu in September with smaller standard portions and meat as an add-on, a change My Edmonds News described as an effort to make meals more affordable. Arnies' sign named the business climate as its reason for closing. Two blocks away, a newcomer opened with a daytime-only schedule, and a longtime restaurant cut its portion sizes.
The Landing's next stage depends on the Port's process. In June 2025, 1010 Development said it would release a hotel rendering later in its permit process. The Port has said design review will include opportunities for public input.
The Port Commission's meeting page lists a commission meeting on Tuesday, November 24, at 10 a.m. Its October 27 agenda included a quarterly report on the Port's commercial properties, the category that covers the Landing. Anyone who wants a say in what replaces a 45-year dinner spot will find the agendas and minutes on that page, the same place the 11 meetings that produced the current lease were published.
If you own near the Edmonds waterfront and want to know how a project like the Landing redevelopment could affect your street over the next few years, Dani Robinett follows these Port decisions closely and is happy to walk through what she's seeing. Schedule a Consultation whenever the timing is right for you.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Dani is dedicated to helping you find your dream home and assisting with any selling needs you may have. Contact her today for a free consultation for buying, selling, renting, or investing in Washington.